RobN185
TPF Noob!
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2011
- Messages
- 617
- Reaction score
- 293
- Location
- France
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
These are indeed quite nice.
Not quite as nice, I think, as the remarks you're getting, but very nice!
I don't really get #1. Generally I am fine with portraits in landscape etc, I'm not seeing any reason for the landscape here. The out of focus trees in the foreground are an interesting choice, since this sort of thing lends a slightly voyeuristic feeling -- the viewer is more "present" in the frame, watching the girl. This feels like a still from a movie from just before something quite unpleasant happens.
#2, frankly, she looks a bit like she's going on to feel herself up a bit. Yes, I know she's doing a classic mom thing, holding her belly. I don't think I would have kept this one, though.
#5 feels a little tightly framed, to me.
Tree branches growing out of her head in #2 and #6, not an issue for me, but it drives some people nuts.
These are quibbles, though. For me the bigger issue is 'what on earth is this pregnant young woman doing out in the woods in the snow, without enough clothes on? Doesn't she know that the light isn't particularly appealing, and that she could freeze to death?!!'
That's still a pretty minor issue. She looks good, she looks happy, you didn't do anything particularly weird, you hit some cute and appealing notes throughout. I assume the customer is happy as anything, and justifiably so.
I think what he is trying to say, is he likes #4.