It does work better I think Paige in the B&W you did.
For me this is one of those photos that unless it's something really significant I scrap it and move on, because otherwise it's going to take a lot of time and work to get anything worthwhile. If I knew the image is good, I'd work on it; if it's something maybe disappointing but not that important or easy enough to photograph again, that's when I am aggravated with myself that I messed up the exposure! but it's not worth it so I'll just try again.