Rate the photo above you

[NJKILLSYOU]

 

[Fender5388]

Perfect capture moment on the trick, nice lighting on the ramp, did you use a light? 8.5/10


liamedit3 by Skateboard C 91, on Flickr

i used three lights, thanks

 

[Bend The Light]

I like it, love the "High Key" aspect, the reflection, and the simplicity. Very nice 9/10


Teasel at Ynis-Hir SOOC by http://bendthelight.me.uk, on Flickr

 

[Nightstr]

^9/10 very nice!

 

[Starskream666]

nice overall tone and i like the colours, not sure what the subject is though, 7/10


This is the first photo i ever took, i know there are problems with it now like over exposed and blown out snow and the clock is too dark haha but you can still rate it

 

[MWC2]

nice overall tone and i like the colours, not sure what the subject is though, 7/10


This is the first photo i ever took, i know there are problems with it now like over exposed and blown out snow and the clock is too dark haha but you can still rate it

It needs to be straightened, the snow looks blown in a few areas and I'm not sure how I'm feeling about the placement of the clock, I think I want it moved more to the left but then I'm not sure how the image would look with having the wall it is attached to come into play. I also would like to see the face of the clock a little brighter, as it is it is not drawing my attention enough. Overall I'm not really drawn into this one. I give it a 6/10

 

[Starskream666]

That is some sharrrrp focus, i like it, nice lighting and expression on the pug 9/10


montee by Skateboard C 91, on Flickr

 

[Bend The Light]

I think you have used the DoF well in this image...it is difficult to shoot a long snout and keep it in focus, so work with what you have and make it a fun shot, like this. Could be messy on the lenses, though! Wish the rest of his nose was in shot, but that's my only real niggle. Nice, fun shot. 7/10


Ben by http://bendthelight.me.uk, on Flickr

 

[Starskream666]

Nice capture with the droplets and i like how you can clearly see how the dog is moving, but the colours are pretty bland and i think you could of done with dodging the face a bit because on my monitor at least i cant see his eyes without really looking hard. 6/10


burd by Skateboard C 91, on Flickr

 

[jackiex_x]

I'm no expert, but it looks a little bit dark for my liking and maybe would have been nice if you'd zoomed in a bit? But good photo as regards getting the action, getting the bird in mid flight. I'd say 7/10.


Here's mine....

I was messing around with the camera in the living room yesterday and think I managed to capture the feeling of a rainy day afternoon, looking thru the window into the street. I know it's dark, but it was getting dark so that's how I wanted it to look.

 

[Starskream666]

Dark n grainy is how i wanted it, but thanks

 

[jackiex_x]

Dark n grainy is how i wanted it, but thanks

See, I said I'm no expert

 

[Shadowbox]

Dark n grainy is how i wanted it, but thanks

See, I said I'm no expert

You don't know the artistic intentions of the photographer if they don't state so, don't think you're not an expert just because of their response .. this is the rate the photo thread above you based on YOUR feelings/thoughts.. not based on 'how the photographer wanted it' unless they say so BEFORE hand and ask if they achieved the effect they wanted.

Jackie your photo definitely shows darkness and I think I would like it better if you focused outside the window and the lace was even across the frame. I'd say 6/10


agirllake (1 of 1) by lifebyme, on Flickr

 

[Ballistics]

I don't know what it is, but the crop doesn't really strike me as appealing. I feel like it's a bit unbalanced. 6/10


Ben 2 by Compressed Memories, on Flickr

 

[Shadowbox]

Well I also have it with a horizontal crop and with a larger vertical crop, not to take the thread off topic but I want to give the photo to her mom so which crop would work best? Thanks!