Rate the photo above you

[margosoriginals]

ErinP709 I can't see your photo, so I will just critique the one above! I give it a 9/10. Could be a little bit lighter, but it really works as a dark shot. I agree with Wrin about the round theme, the compsition and colors are amazing!

 

[mishele]

Hi - this is my first post. I spent the last hour reading through this thread and it is amazing! I feel like it is the best hour of learning I have spent on photography.

I give the above photo a 9/10. I really like the composition with the 2 drops and how the "round" theme carries through the entire image. Like I said...I am new, so my critique might not be very good...but I tried.

Thanks.....you did a great job!!! Welcome to the forum!!! Edit you thread and post a picture of yours in it!! That way we can continue the C&C!!

 

[ErinP709]

Finally figured it out...

 

[mishele]

margos.........fun shot. The shot looks a little soft, meaning that you missed a sharp focus. Keep shooting!! Macro shots are tough!! 6/10
Erin....Again fun shot. Beautiful little girl but you cut off her arm.....=( Try to remember to watch your backgrounds, this one is very busy. Try a smaller f/stop, you'll blur the background more. 5/10

 

[JWellman]

I'm such a fan of yours Mishele. I don't even know what I'm looking at but chances are it's a flower. Despite not knowing, it doesn't really matter because I could sit and look at it all day. The colors are spectacular and I wish it were hanging on my wall. Since every picture is not exactly perfect, I guess the only thing throwing my vision off is the blackened corner and a couple specks of what looks to be dust. 9/10

Taken today at a bridal shower.

 

[Bend The Light]

A lovely moment, and shows clearly the generations. Lovely emotions etc, the old lady looks extremely happy, and I am not even bothered by the lack of eyes...she's clearly in a moment of fun/happiness. Only niggle is that it is very tightly cropped/framed. This leads to a "random hand" on the right. I know it's the old lady's hand, but it is disconnected. 7/10


Sunset over the hills at Croeslyn 3 by http://bendthelight.me.uk, on Flickr

 

[lawrencebrussel]

I'll rate it 7/10.

& Loved it

 

[KaPOWitsCHRIS]

A lovely moment, and shows clearly the generations. Lovely emotions etc, the old lady looks extremely happy, and I am not even bothered by the lack of eyes...she's clearly in a moment of fun/happiness. Only niggle is that it is very tightly cropped/framed. This leads to a "random hand" on the right. I know it's the old lady's hand, but it is disconnected. 7/10


Sunset over the hills at Croeslyn 3 by http://bendthelight.me.uk, on Flickr

8/10 I love the colours

 

[Hokie1985]

A bit dark for my taste but like the broodiness of it...7/10

_DSC0259 by Hokie1985, on Flickr

 

[thomas30]

5/10, It is impossible to identify what kind of animal it is! Otherwise, the quality of pic, contrast, hues everything is fine.

 

[Starskream666]

You didn't post a picture so

ginner edit1 by Skateboard C 91, on Flickr

 

[brittanyrose864]

Love the lighting and black/white theme.

Rating: 8/10

 

[pthrift]

Brittany: I like the colors. 8/10.


rainbow by patrick.thrift, on Flickr

 

[kittenbreath]

pthrift: I mean, you captured the rainbow well but i really dislike the crop. 5/10.

 

[Starskream666]

pthrift: I mean, you captured the rainbow well but i really dislike the crop. 5/10.

Nice dawg, quite a boring backdrop though and underexposed? too dark, i'm guessing it was taken at night? would be nice to see it in a more sunny atmosphere 6/10


liamedit2 by Skateboard C 91, on Flickr