Rule of 3 (or Thirds)

[Markie Madden]

I saw this in several different places, one being a tutorial done by users of my photo software, called Paint.net. It rang a vague bell from what I learned in high school. Fortunately it was a decent tutorial complete with screen shots. So here's my first attempt at a crop using the rule of thirds. This is the original.

 

[Markie Madden]

And this, assuming my phone cooperates, should be the crop.

 

[The_Traveler]

I think you have misunderstood the 'rule of thirds.'
Try this link and see if it is meaningful Rule of Thirds - Digital Photography School

OOPS, now you've posted the crop and I feel silly.
I would look at some way to remove that little distracting thingie on the right.

 

[Markie Madden]

You mean the other flower?

 

[The_Traveler]

Do you want comments on that photo about issues other than the crop?

 

[Markie Madden]

It was just a shot I was messing with for the rule of thirds, the example I saw in one tutorial was of the Washington Monument so I tried to find something similar around the house. I just wanted something to practice on in regards to the crop.

But, if you'd like to give other comments, just be gentle with me, remember, it's my first time !

 

[Derrel]

The rule of thirds is kind of a modern-era shortcut, and not a very academic, studied thing. It's one of the shortcut ways that have been developed to dumb-down composition to a bite-sized sort of soundbite equivalent. There are many,many,many images that do not use this so-caleld "rule". In fact, the rule of thirds has lead to a strategy where many beginners place people 1/3 of the way off to the "short" side of a horizontal frame, have the people look toward the short side of the frame, and then, fill the other 2/3 of the frame with absolutely useless dead space.

Photos and Stuff Kill The Rule of Thirds

Photos and Stuff Rule of Thirds Redux

Just some background information that you might find helpful.

 

[Markie Madden]

Oh, I understand that many rules are made to be broken, as stated in the above linked article in The Traveler's post. But as I'm just learning how to manipulate images, I saw it in the tutorial and wanted to give it a try. Stuff like this, I learn best by doing. And, it might be simpler even to just frame the shot this way when you shoot it, if possible.

 

[Derrel]

If you wish to learn about photographic composition, I would go to this web site, and check out the free articles the author offers. He has an #abolishROT hashtag there. The "rule of thirds" is really NOT a fundamental of design, nor of composition, but more of a modern-era urban legend, a bit of folk wisdom, something easily passed along in a sentence or two, and honestly, it's NOT, in any way, part of design,nor compositional theory.

Canon of Design Table of Contents

Don't worry about the rule of thirds, because honestly, it is not important. It's NOT the key to composition. The elements and principles of design are what one wants to understand. The actual, real, academic principles of the field of design, not the misinformed folk wisdom from Popular Mechanics magazine.

Your flower photo for example, has a serious problem with repetition of lines; extremely patterned background; and a strong figure/ground problem. Those fundamental issues are something that the "rule of thirds" cannot overcome. The issue is that the brickwork has an exceptionally strong pattern; THAT is what dominates the image--the strong, repeating pattern, with very strong, numerous lines. The background in your photo is very,very strong, but the foreground subject, is very small. The background is a mass of shapes, in repetition. With a very strong horizontal direction. Of uniform size. And a hard, masonry texture. The dominance is all in the background.

If you look here, you will see what is meant by the elements and principles of design.
Elements and principles of design

 

[Markie Madden]

Well it did teach me something useful. I've been trying to figure out how to put grid lines or some other type of reference into images, for example, when I want to put text into an image like I would do for a book cover. In other words, a line or two that would show me where the center or the edge would be, so all the text lines up.

 

[The_Traveler]

All of that can be done easily with the various options on the crop tool.
That will superimpose a grid or thirds lines, etc and then you can put temporary lines on the photo to act as guides

 

[Designer]

Oh, I understand that many rules are made to be broken, as stated in the above linked article in The Traveler's post. But as I'm just learning how to manipulate images, I saw it in the tutorial and wanted to give it a try. Stuff like this, I learn best by doing. And, it might be simpler even to just frame the shot this way when you shoot it, if possible.

I would caution you (and any newbie) about trying to adhere to some arbitrary compositional "rules". As Derrel has written, that is simply a shorthand attempt to teach some principles of composition that newbs can understand and follow.

Yes, it is in editing that you can often crop the image to improve the balance, and your example has done something along those lines.

Get hold of some reading material on composition, and realize there are other "rules" put into play as well. The problem with our fast-paced life these days is that everyone wants a shortcut. A shortcut to winning a game, a shortcut to reading a novel, and a shortcut to composition, when learning as much as you can about it will yield an "intuitive" feel for composition for which you don't have to ponder the "rules" as you're composing.

 

[Dave442]

You also changed the aspect ratio when you did the crop, don't know if that was intentional. In the new crop the flower is pointing towards the short side, like it is trying to get away from the other flower. Remember the background plays a role. What was the background/foreground in the Washington Monument photo that was used as an example?

You might just try taking 50 shots of that flower and move around and place the flower in different locations in the frame. Then go through the shots and really narrow it down to the one that gives you the composition you like the best. Find out what you like.

 

[Markie Madden]

All of that can be done easily with the various options on the crop tool.
That will superimpose a grid or thirds lines, etc and then you can put temporary lines on the photo to act as guides

Thanks Traveler,I had to go through a tutorial on my software, called Paint.net (a free alternative to Photo Shop), and that's where I saw the rule. I was testing not only my cropping ability but the lesson on putting the grid lines over an image, so I can align text!

 

[Markie Madden]

You also changed the aspect ratio when you did the crop, don't know if that was intentional. In the new crop the flower is pointing towards the short side, like it is trying to get away from the other flower. Remember the background plays a role. What was the background/foreground in the Washington Monument photo that was used as an example?

You might just try taking 50 shots of that flower and move around and place the flower in different locations in the frame. Then go through the shots and really narrow it down to the one that gives you the composition you like the best. Find out what you like.

Thanks for the info Dave. In the Washington Monument photo, the image was taken directly in front, so in the gorgeous you see the reflecting pool and the small tree line to each side.

As far as changing the ratio, I didn't do it in purpose. But I had to resize the images to be able to post them (they were larger than 40mb) and I just did a quick resize on them for demonstration purposes.