On its own, I also like the photoshopped version, the colours are not soooo off that no one would believe you the sunset any more. Quite to the contrary, I should say, you could have me believe your sunset was like this --- as long as I don't see the second photo along with the first .
I have come back to this three times. Im about as much help as a headache. I like both, but for some reason I keep leaning towards the first shot. NIce stuff. !!