which edit of this photo do you prefer?

[JbleezyJ]

I recently tried editing an old photo of mine and I have a totally new look on the photo after editing it the second time. I now prefer my second edit but I don't know which edit do you think does the image more justice?

Here was my original edit
1:

Here was my second edit I did today
2:

And here is how the original raw file looked like:

At first I thought it was too red but now I'm kinda liking the red. Iono. let me know what you guys think.

 

[Dominantly]

Middle one looks best to me.

 

[Sbuxo]

the 1st one.
i think the blue in the sky and road does it for me.

 

[chmille]

I would say you need to find a happy medium between the 2nd edit and the original. If you want the road to look more realistic and concrete is hard to master, b/c I'm sure and I know I have troubles with it. It just appears pretty blue in the 2nd image. Just my opinion though.

 

[KenC]

I like the original edit. The blue/violet night sky looks more natural and, probably more important, it sets off the orange light trail better.

 

[nahtanoj]

#1. very neat pic.

 

[jaymac]

IMO:
I would like to see the sky in #1 and the road in #2 together. Don't know if that's possible or not...:er:

Good pics either way. :thumbup:

 

[minpingurl1]

the 1st one.
i think the blue in the sky and road does it for me.

Same here.

 

[NikonNewbie]

#1...fo sho

 

[8ball]

Middle one

 

[MissCream]

#2 for me.

 

[brownieapple]

my vote is for the second one.

 

[Nikon_Dude]

I like #1

 

[timfrommass]

Yeah I agree with the 1/2 combo. I love the sky on #1, but everything else on #2

 

[cletusjermal]

Yeah I agree with the 1/2 combo. I love the sky on #1, but everything else on #2

X2