Which one is better?

[Jeff Canes]

#1

#2

PS: This is the same negative

 

[Nikon Fan]

I vote #2, BEAutiful colors Great shot as well!!!

 

[thebeginning]

i know exactly where that was taken (pretty sure). was it taken in the yosemite valley? i'm pretty sure it's where Ansel Adams took his "winter storm clearing" shot.

to answer your question, i like the second one better...for some reason the first one is much softer, which i guess could be more of an artistic style, but im not so sure if it works for this setting.

 

[aprilraven]

love the second one better...never even noticed the waterfall in the first shot...
that looks like a great place to take pictures..or just sit and stare...thinking.

beautiful shot...

 

[pursuer]

I definatly prefer the second version, beautiful location.

 

[LaFoto]

I voted in my son's name who immediately said that he prefers the first over the second.

(Later he said, "No, no, vote 4, heehee, 'this is BAD, dude, start over'", but he did not mean it )

 

[danalec99]

I like both the pictures.

Would vote for a lil more sharpness!

 

[Jeff Canes]

I scanned #1 on my Epson 4180 flatbed scanner. The colors are basically as scanned. #2 was done on a drum scanner by a local lab. They adjusted the colors and cleared it up. I send both of them to MPIX.com for printing the other day. I should have them by next Monday.

Personally I am not happy with ether, but I am far happier with #1 because the colors are truer and on the screen there is less pixxing (can’t think of the right term). Do agree that #1 is to dark on the waterfall side, but tree area is closer to the actual lighting. With #2 colors are all-wrong


Beginnging you’re right on the location. Also it was taken some time between noon and 1:30 pm. With a Rollei TLR and Kodak 100T