Which version do you prefer?

[407370]

Hi All,

See below 3 versions of the same photo. It a garden weather vane in the shape of a WW2 British spitfire:

1

2

3

This is the original:

Comments always welcome.

CHEERS
JBO

 

[Rickbb]

#2 for me.

 

[10acres]

2. The contrast between the plane and the clouds is more appealing to me.

 

[Jeff15]

Two for me too ...

 

[denum]

Agreed, #2.

 

[407370]

Thanks all for the input.

I was leaning towards 3 as I like the motion blur.

CHEERS
JBO

 

[acparsons]

#2 is the best.

 

[smoke665]

Sorry, but I preferred the original.

 

[otherprof]

Hi All,

See below 3 versions of the same photo. It a garden weather vane in the shape of a WW2 British spitfire:

1
View attachment 288780

2
View attachment 288781

3
View attachment 288782

This is the original:
View attachment 288783

Comments always welcome.

CHEERS
JBO

The original does it for me.

 

[407370]

Thanks for the comments.

Actually thinking about it, I like the uncropped original as well.

CHEERS
JBO

 

[jeffashman]

The original has more room to "fly" in.

 

[greybeard]

Two

 

[ACHILLEAS]

I do not like it cropped and you can see the dirt on the lens on the right side in photo #2. I worked on the original a little bit to make it like a ww2 movie.

 

[DanOstergren]

#3 for me. I like the movement in the blur. It also has much less haloing around certain details, whereas the other two have significant haloing on the arch that's holding the plane, giving them the appearance of being over edited.