Why did my thread get closed?

[new photographer]

I hadn't posted my newest pictures which I was hoping for advice about?
Am I not allowed to post anymore?
What did I do?

 

[RauschPhotography]

:roll:

 

[gsgary]

Post it then we can rip it apart

 

[new photographer]

*TPF prides itself on encouraging friendly and open discourse regarding photography. Personal attacks on any members as well as TPF Staff will not be tolerated, and these posts will be deleted and the instigators possibly banned.

 

[new photographer]

*TPF prides itself on encouraging friendly and open discourse regarding photography. Personal attacks on any members as well as TPF Staff will not be tolerated, and these posts will be deleted and the instigators possibly banned.

If you promise not to attack me I will

 

[RauschPhotography]

So we'll give you advice, you'll take it wrong and then consider it an "attack"?

 

[new photographer]

So we'll give you advice, you'll take it wrong and then consider it an "attack"?

No. I asked for advice. Thats what I want and need. The first one was taken on my phone so try not to critique the focus rather than the art behind it.
The second critique everything about.
Thankyou.

 

[PhotoWrangler]

 

[vtf]

Fool me once, shame on you.
You know the rest.

 

[Stradawhovious]

Oh......Hai!

Welcome back! I see you have a new shiny screen name. Very nice.

Happy tolling!

 

[SrBiscuit]

Didnt see the last thread I don't think, so I'll bite.

1. selective coloring...ehhhhhh not a fan. What was your focal point here?....The girls or the graf?

2. Out of focus, fingers/hand chopped off, WB too cold. area under eye (cam right) looks blown.

*edit*

ohhhh ****....is this karissa "best" again?

IF it is, guys, let's give critique and hope that she will take it well and continue to be a part of the community and learn. :thumbup:

if this is a trolling effort, then you got me again. good on you.:thumbup:

 

[new photographer]

Fool me once, shame on you.
You know the rest.

Im going to ignore and that and point out my own critique(cos theres 11 people looking but none talking and say: The second one has ALOT of noise i opened it in gimp after i posted it here and reduced the noise and it looks alot better!

 

[PhotoWrangler]

Im going to ignore and that and point out my own critique(cos theres 11 people looking but none talking and say: The second one has ALOT of noise i opened it in gimp after i posted it here and reduced the noise and it looks alot better!

Well if you're going to critique your own stuff... why even bother asking us? TROLL.

 

[new photographer]

Didnt see the last thread I don't think, so I'll bite.

1. selective coloring...ehhhhhh not a fan. What was your focal point here?....The girls or the graf?

2. Out of focus, fingers/hand chopped off, WB too cold. area under eye (cam right) looks blown.

*edit*

ohhhh ****....is this karissa "best" again?

IF it is, guys, let's give critique and hope that she will take it well and continue to be a part of the community and learn. :thumbup:

if this is a trolling effort, then you got me again. good on you.:thumbup:

Ok, so I was kinda trying to make it about the graffiti. Should I have just cut the girls out?
And so next time take photo further back and change my white balance setting (I havent edited the photo) and sorry I dont understand what you mean by blown? Big under the eye? Thanks !

 

[SrBiscuit]

idk....call me a sucker, but i vote if she returned to learn we should give her a chance to start over....