...very good,scott.I tend to agree,somewhat.I guess I just would have rather seen these two individuals pulled over and given a citation,rather than closing the entire road,so to speak.
while I am not personally a fan of locking threads, once a thread reaches a certain level of "chaotic posting", it becomes difficult and tiresome to clean up.
not only do the offending posts have to be deleted or edited, but people that QUOTED those posts have to be edited. pulling out a bunch of inflammatory posts can often leave weird conversation gaps where it becomes difficult to figure out what happened.
you could be right about just going after the offenders though.
but, lets suppose we do that. warnings leading to infractions leading to temporary bans, and so on.
how many people will just complain that bans are too heavy handed when a simple lock could have stopped the whole thing without someone getting banned?
whats interesting to note, is that the Mod team gets the occasional complaint about "over-moderation" on the forum, and just as many complaints about the forum being "under-moderated" no matter which route is taken, some group of people is going to be unhappy about it.
contrary to popular belief (as I have recently learned myself) the Mods dont make the rules here. we are TOLD what the rules are, and expected to enforce them.
while we ARE given a certain amount of leeway and discretion, it is usually used in favor of NOT banning a repeat offender and instead just sending them a PM or giving an infraction. this kindness is usually met with angry PM's in return, and/or complaint threads started (both are technically against forum rules BTW, something else we usually let slide a bit)
surprisingly enough, how to handle forum arguments and spiraling threads is probably THE most discussed topic by the mod team, but we have yet to come up with anything that appears to satisfy everyone.
the best solution for everyone, is of course, for people to simply NOT engage in petty and inflammatory arguments on the forum. some people are just absolutely insistent on getting the last word in and "proving" their point even after Mods have posted warnings. If you want to be mad at someone for ruining perfectly good threads, blame the people arguing in them. not the Mods for putting a stop to it in a manner you might not totally agree with.