Comment on some pics

AnthonyCorbo · Dec 30, 2008

Came back form los cabos mexico and took some pics let me know what you think:thumbup:
thanks in advance

AlexColeman · Dec 30, 2008

Like 1 on the second, the rocks have no detail and yet arent silouhetes.

saltface · Dec 30, 2008

I think number two was my fave. The first one has decent composition and could have been really nice using HDR. IMHO.

Aggressor · Dec 31, 2008

I like #1 & #2. Interesting composition on both. Tweaking the image by using curves or saturation bump would make it even better by making the colors more vibrant.

#1 - I would clone out the birds in the sky. They're too small in the photo anyway and, at least in this size, look like dirt spots. And maybe clone out the boat to the left... It looks out of place.

#3 - Rule of thirds helped a little here, although, personally, I find objects against a horizon by themselves a little boring. It may be difficult in this case, but I find landscapes that have something interesting in the foreground, midground, and background are the most captivating.

AnthonyCorbo · Dec 31, 2008

saltface said:
I think number two was my fave. The first one has decent composition and could have been really nice using HDR. IMHO.

Yeah i agree it would have been sweet for an hdr but i was on a boat and pretty seasick.. :lol:

AnthonyCorbo · Dec 31, 2008

Aggressor said:
I like #1 & #2. Interesting composition on both. Tweaking the image by using curves or saturation bump would make it even better by making the colors more vibrant.

#1 - I would clone out the birds in the sky. They're too small in the photo anyway and, at least in this size, look like dirt spots. And maybe clone out the boat to the left... It looks out of place.

#3 - Rule of thirds helped a little here, although, personally, I find objects against a horizon by themselves a little boring. It may be difficult in this case, but I find landscapes that have something interesting in the foreground, midground, and background are the most captivating.

Thanks for your advice i tried to adjust the first picture and came out with this