- Joined
- May 1, 2008
- Messages
- 25,422
- Reaction score
- 5,003
- Location
- UK - England
- Website
- www.deviantart.com
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
So if you've read my earlier writing here How to structure your posts to get critiques on your work (C&C) | Photography Forum you already know how to do your best to get feedback on your photos. You know how to present yourself and even start the process of self critique.
However there is another side of the coin that we all need to learn, its simple, but a few tricks and tips can really help get the best out of it - and that is how to respond to feedback that you've gotten on your photography. So below are a few pointers that you can use which should help you deal with critique and also improve your chances of getting more in the future.
1) Be polite and take the time to say thank you. Yes that sounds really very very basic; but we've all been guilty of coming onto the site (maybe at work or browsing without logging in) and reading our thread, reading the comments and then not saying anything.
Whilst it is not expected, the very least we can do is pause for a moment and post to say thank you to those who have offered up their time and ideas t post and give their feedback - even if its something as short as "Great shot" or "bad shot". Yes we thank those who even don't like our photography because each viewpoint is a valid critique.
This is the first and easiest thing we can do, this simple act of politeness.
2) Don't get upset.
Ok so some people might not like your photos. You might like them - you might have put lots of effort into them. Other people that you know might like them - but all that doesn't matter.
You've posted your photos and asked for peoples honest opinions. In that light a positive or a negative feedback is both equally valid.
3) Learn to separate opinion from reason.
When a person says they like or dislike something that is good, it gives you a base line to work from. When you get critique and comments you'll also likely get not only an opinion, but also a reasoning for that opinion. So put the opinion to one side for now and read the reasoning behind it. This is the gold mine; this is the key information you really want and will really benefit from. The WHY of an opinion. It's what you came here and posted for.
Now the reasoning will be varied, some of it you might understand and some not. When a person stats a theory or concept as the reason for their like or dislike use that term - ask them about it and also do some research of your own (search the forum/google/books). It's unlikely that in a forum reply you will get a fully detailed outline of a theory or concept; so do some research and you can find articles in various sources which will go into much more depth. Now you've got some structure to your self teaching!
4) Accept that sometimes people will argue.
Yep sometimes people forget themselves and suddenly your photo has generated a mini-argument or disagreement between other members.
Don't panic!
What this means is that you've another gold-mine right in your thread! Yep you really have and you don't even have to take sides or get into the fight.
Because what you have is two strongly opposing viewpoints. So the best thing you can do is to ask for clarification from both parties. Ask them to go into more detail about their viewpoints - get them to explain things - chances are if they are already passionate about their viewpoint and facts that you will get an answer. Now you can gather together those viewpoints - gather up the facts behind them and now you've got some information from which you can make your choice.
5) Always ask for clarification on something you don't understand.
Yep sometimes people will say things that are just going right over your head; that's not a problem not in the least. Simply take a moment to ask them to clarify - or elaborate upon their point more so. It helps to also ask if they could provide a reference or link to further information on their viewpoint (if its based upon a theory).
6) Remember that you don't have to agree with everyone.
You are your own person and its up to you to make your own choices in things. However even if you don't agree, remember the first point and remain polite. If you must reject an opinion or feedback do so in a polite manner. If there are reasons why you reject it then state them honestly and openly. Best result is that you might generate some discussion which could further your learning.
7) Learn that debate and disagreement need not nor should ever be a fight.
Keep personal comments out of things, even if the other side slings the first insult. Ack professional and stick to the facts and the reasoning. You're here to learn not get drawn into petty arguments so be the leader in your thread and stick to the facts.
But wait wait a sec overread I haven't got any replies yet and I did everything you've suggested too! Do people hate me?
Nope chances are they don't but there are a few tricks that can help matters;
1) Weekends - if you post on a weekend things are slower; people are off doing other things and forum activity dwindles. A bit tip if you want feedback is to not post on weekends - post on weekdays.
2) Wrong time - each site has peek periods where its more active; you can get a rough idea just being around and seeing when the site is most active and when its most dead. So time your threads to match that. That way you've got the most chance of people seeing and responding.
3) Bump the post - if tis been a few days or the post has fallen onto page two of the subsection its in then give it a bump. So long as you're not abusing it mods won't bite you (really we won't - promise). But don't just say "bump". Be specific - ask if there is something wrong or something right - ask again if any have any feed back, no matter how small.
So after all that it sounds like there's a fair bit of work in things; but there isn't. Not really.
Most of it is remaining polite - being respectful and also asking questions. You can also debate and discuss things and when you're learning and talking to other photographers you'll find it a joy to get a little deeper into the subject. Even some of the more dry maths and physics is information you can stash away which might come in handy or at least help you better understand what is going on and why.
So good luck in getting critique and enjoy your talks on the site
However there is another side of the coin that we all need to learn, its simple, but a few tricks and tips can really help get the best out of it - and that is how to respond to feedback that you've gotten on your photography. So below are a few pointers that you can use which should help you deal with critique and also improve your chances of getting more in the future.
1) Be polite and take the time to say thank you. Yes that sounds really very very basic; but we've all been guilty of coming onto the site (maybe at work or browsing without logging in) and reading our thread, reading the comments and then not saying anything.
Whilst it is not expected, the very least we can do is pause for a moment and post to say thank you to those who have offered up their time and ideas t post and give their feedback - even if its something as short as "Great shot" or "bad shot". Yes we thank those who even don't like our photography because each viewpoint is a valid critique.
This is the first and easiest thing we can do, this simple act of politeness.
2) Don't get upset.
Ok so some people might not like your photos. You might like them - you might have put lots of effort into them. Other people that you know might like them - but all that doesn't matter.
You've posted your photos and asked for peoples honest opinions. In that light a positive or a negative feedback is both equally valid.
3) Learn to separate opinion from reason.
When a person says they like or dislike something that is good, it gives you a base line to work from. When you get critique and comments you'll also likely get not only an opinion, but also a reasoning for that opinion. So put the opinion to one side for now and read the reasoning behind it. This is the gold mine; this is the key information you really want and will really benefit from. The WHY of an opinion. It's what you came here and posted for.
Now the reasoning will be varied, some of it you might understand and some not. When a person stats a theory or concept as the reason for their like or dislike use that term - ask them about it and also do some research of your own (search the forum/google/books). It's unlikely that in a forum reply you will get a fully detailed outline of a theory or concept; so do some research and you can find articles in various sources which will go into much more depth. Now you've got some structure to your self teaching!
4) Accept that sometimes people will argue.
Yep sometimes people forget themselves and suddenly your photo has generated a mini-argument or disagreement between other members.
Don't panic!
What this means is that you've another gold-mine right in your thread! Yep you really have and you don't even have to take sides or get into the fight.
Because what you have is two strongly opposing viewpoints. So the best thing you can do is to ask for clarification from both parties. Ask them to go into more detail about their viewpoints - get them to explain things - chances are if they are already passionate about their viewpoint and facts that you will get an answer. Now you can gather together those viewpoints - gather up the facts behind them and now you've got some information from which you can make your choice.
5) Always ask for clarification on something you don't understand.
Yep sometimes people will say things that are just going right over your head; that's not a problem not in the least. Simply take a moment to ask them to clarify - or elaborate upon their point more so. It helps to also ask if they could provide a reference or link to further information on their viewpoint (if its based upon a theory).
6) Remember that you don't have to agree with everyone.
You are your own person and its up to you to make your own choices in things. However even if you don't agree, remember the first point and remain polite. If you must reject an opinion or feedback do so in a polite manner. If there are reasons why you reject it then state them honestly and openly. Best result is that you might generate some discussion which could further your learning.
7) Learn that debate and disagreement need not nor should ever be a fight.
Keep personal comments out of things, even if the other side slings the first insult. Ack professional and stick to the facts and the reasoning. You're here to learn not get drawn into petty arguments so be the leader in your thread and stick to the facts.
But wait wait a sec overread I haven't got any replies yet and I did everything you've suggested too! Do people hate me?
Nope chances are they don't but there are a few tricks that can help matters;
1) Weekends - if you post on a weekend things are slower; people are off doing other things and forum activity dwindles. A bit tip if you want feedback is to not post on weekends - post on weekdays.
2) Wrong time - each site has peek periods where its more active; you can get a rough idea just being around and seeing when the site is most active and when its most dead. So time your threads to match that. That way you've got the most chance of people seeing and responding.
3) Bump the post - if tis been a few days or the post has fallen onto page two of the subsection its in then give it a bump. So long as you're not abusing it mods won't bite you (really we won't - promise). But don't just say "bump". Be specific - ask if there is something wrong or something right - ask again if any have any feed back, no matter how small.
So after all that it sounds like there's a fair bit of work in things; but there isn't. Not really.
Most of it is remaining polite - being respectful and also asking questions. You can also debate and discuss things and when you're learning and talking to other photographers you'll find it a joy to get a little deeper into the subject. Even some of the more dry maths and physics is information you can stash away which might come in handy or at least help you better understand what is going on and why.
So good luck in getting critique and enjoy your talks on the site