Ideas for eyes....Do you like the edit I did? Or....No?

[karissabphotography]

This was a self-portrait hence why its not SPECTACULAR or anything LOL

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

They are over processed.

 

[karissabphotography]

They are over processed.

Can you please not comment on my threads. Thankyou

 

[Malone]

The mascara is flaky and messy..

 

[karissabphotography]

Why wouldn't you?
Im really not worried and I could have cloned it out but I like it...

 

[Bitter Jeweler]

I gave you constructive critique. That's what you are asking for .

 

[karissabphotography]

Regardless,
I dont want you posting on my threads please.
I dont know how much more nicely I could ask?

 

[iNick]

It's crooked, the bridge of the nose is completely over exposed and the whole shot is over processed.

On a side note, you're doing yourself a terrible injustice by asking Bitter to not comment on your threads. He has been a fantastic help and motivator to many many people on this site. You could learn a lot from him but instead you're boxing yourself out because you think you know everything. If you're going to get mad at people for giving honest opinions then don't post C&C threads. post your shots you think are great in the gallery and wait for no one to comment on how much they love them.

 

[karissabphotography]

Just so you know,
I asked him to not post because everytime I go on this site he insults me either outright or subtly

I would love to have helpful feedback from him but he seems to only say negative feedback with no way on how to fix something.
For instance,
If I dont like a photo :I dont like this photo BECAUSE.......you could try this to fix it....
If I like a photo: I like this photo BECAUSE......

Not just "over-processed" with no explanation as to why it is, what processing he would use etc.
These sorts of remarks are unhelpful because how do I learn anything other than that I am obviously a ****ty photographer (I assume by the way everyone just hates all my photos and cant be bothered saying why)

 

[iNick]

Just so you know,
I asked him to not post because everytime I go on this site he insults me either outright or subtly

I would love to have helpful feedback from him but he seems to only say negative feedback with no way on how to fix something.
For instance,
If I dont like a photo :I dont like this photo BECAUSE.......you could try this to fix it....
If I like a photo: I like this photo BECAUSE......

Not just "over-processed" with no explanation as to why it is, what processing he would use etc.
These sorts of remarks are unhelpful because how do I learn anything other than that I am obviously a ****ty photographer (I assume by the way everyone just hates all my photos and cant be bothered saying why)

The answer you are looking for is essentially, It is over-processed because you did too much processing. i would do less processing.. there really isn't much more to say other than, learn photoshop better (or at all)..... you just need to relax and stop thinking people are personally attacking you because we don't like your photos....

 

[karissabphotography]

I only feel that way on this site?
Surely I cant be misreading EVERYTHING.
I post on FroKnowsPhoto.com and they critique my work. They would say, This works-That doesn't-Try doing this instead.
I don't feel negative towards them.
Maybe Im too sensitive?

 

[kundalini]

Ideas for eyes....Do you like the edit I did? Or....No?

No. They are over processed.

 

[iNick]

I only feel that way on this site?
Surely I cant be misreading EVERYTHING.
I post on FroKnowsPhoto.com and they critique my work. They would say, This works-That doesn't-Try doing this instead.
I don't feel negative towards them.
Maybe Im too sensitive?

If you get such great critique from them why do you feel the need to come here, especially if we are so rude and insulting?

 

[TwoTwoLeft]

If someone said a photo of mine was "over processed" common sense would tell me to just do less of whatever I did to it.... Maybe "over-processing" was your intention. But there's no way we would know that, since you never bothered to explain what exactly you were going for...

Garbage in, garbage out....

 

[Ryan L]

Regardless,
I dont want you posting on my threads please.
I dont know how much more nicely I could ask?

So put him on your ignore list, then you wont see his posts, and you wont look childish by telling him not to talk to you. Bitter didnt say anything offensive at all.

I only feel that way on this site?
Maybe Im too sensitive?

Do ya think maybe just a LITTLE??