Ideas for eyes....Do you like the edit I did? Or....No?

[gsgary]

Just so you know,
I asked him to not post because everytime I go on this site he insults me either outright or subtly

I would love to have helpful feedback from him but he seems to only say negative feedback with no way on how to fix something.
For instance,
If I dont like a photo :I dont like this photo BECAUSE.......you could try this to fix it....
If I like a photo: I like this photo BECAUSE......

Not just "over-processed" with no explanation as to why it is, what processing he would use etc.
These sorts of remarks are unhelpful because how do I learn anything other than that I am obviously a ****ty photographer (I assume by the way everyone just hates all my photos and cant be bothered saying why)

It could be something to do with the photo being awful

 

[vtf]

Just so you know,
I asked him to not post because everytime I go on this site he insults me either outright or subtly

I would love to have helpful feedback from him but he seems to only say negative feedback with no way on how to fix something.
For instance,
If I dont like a photo 1) I dont like this photo BECAUSE.......you could try this to fix it....
If I like a photo: (2) I like this photo BECAUSE......

Not just "over-processed" with no explanation as to why it is, what processing he would use etc.
These sorts of remarks are unhelpful because how do I learn anything other than that I am obviously a ****ty photographer (I assume by the way everyone just hates all my photos and cant be bothered saying why)

It could be something to do with the photo being awful

1. He didn't say he didn't like it, he said it was overprocessed. I agree.
2. With history like yours, you have to show us something other than the same images we've seen before that got other threads locked and names banned before you get the warm fuzzies. I haven't seen the improvement I would expect over the course of the past few months.
I believe it to be oof. Close ups like this should be nailed or close to it before posting.
It really shows your quality if you don't own your own appearance.