Robin Usagani
Been spending a lot of time on here!
- Joined
- Jun 6, 2010
- Messages
- 10,347
- Reaction score
- 2,174
- Location
- Denver, CO
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos OK to edit
Honestly, Schwetty did not provide a good, honest critique(and fwiw, it was this thread and not another one). He nitpicked every photo based on his perception of what his 'best of 2011' would look like. He also freely admitted that. I also freely admitted that perhaps I should have titled this thread something different to avoid that argument altogether. I believe he said that he felt I should have showed more 'steak' and less of the 'trimmings'...Well, that's all up to personal choices, but criticizing the merit of certain photos because he believes they are more trimmings than steak, isn't exactly valid criticism. I think Schwetty and I are on the same page on this one and, honestly, I believe if he were to do the critique over again knowing what he knows now, this thread would have taken a different turn.
Wow, if that wasn't honest critique, I wonder what my honest critique would sound like. See, making this statement is pretty much stirring the pot again. Grow up man, seriously. I have showed almost all of my work here since day 1. I got sh!t load of critiques from members here. A lot of harsh (but true) ones. If you think I gave this CC only because it is you who posted it, you are totally wrong man. The first post on this thread was really my honest general CC. Then you managed to PM me asking for more detailed CC. Lets go trough this again.
really? This made it to your favorite or best thread? What makes this photo your favorite?