Rate the photo above you

[nemopaice]

hmm 8/10, Nice shot overall, took off for the smudges...

 

[Tigertail]

8/10 Really good composition. Technically it's all there. I could see it having worked in color to be a tad more interesting.

 

[Destin]

I like this photo alot, the fog makes it look pretty darn cool! 8.5/10


Here's mine. FYI, that dust was NOT good for my gear. Haha

 

[Starskream666]

Cool crisp action shot 8/10

 

[kundalini]

Is this a Rorschach test? No clear subject IMO. Hard on the eyes. 5/10 for the attempt anyway.



This is one of my carved pumpkins, illuminated by a tea candle inside.

m

 

[scottfishel]

Very cool concept, and very well done. I honestly thought at first glance that it was just a computer generated image until I focused on the texture of the orange. I'll take away a point because I think others might make the same mistake. 9/10.

My submission is also proof that I need to fire up the weedwacker...

 

[Starskream666]

Is this a Rorschach test? No clear subject IMO. Hard on the eyes. 5/10 for the attempt anyway.
m

No clear subject? the branch is obviously the subject. I know what you mean about hard on the eyes though.

 

[Mitzi]

I'm a newbie but I love the clear sharp lines and the way the light catches the fine hairs on the stalk 7/10

 

[gsgary]

I'm a newbie but I love the clear sharp lines and the way the light catches the fine hairs on the stalk 7/10

Where's your photo, you rate and post one of your own (just doing a bit of policing )

 

[nemopaice]

Just to get the ball rolling again..... I would give the thorns a 5.5/10. No interesting subject matter...
But speaking of a need to cut the grass.....

 

[hayleyfraser24]

I think we have a record breaking thread here! I didnt want to break the chain... you were right to do a bit of policing gsgary! so I rate the last picture 6/10... and only because imo its not that the kind of thing I find interesting, but thats a personal thing. On the technical side of things its a good shot. Here is mine and this was one of my first pictures I took as a girl trying to teach herself photography so it might not be technicly that great but its one on my favourites!

 

[hayleyfraser24]

oops, I was rating the thorns as well... looks like we posted at the same time nemopaice... to keep things fair I thinks the next person needs to rate both the 2 pictures above!

 

[nemopaice]

oops, I was rating the thorns as well... looks like we posted at the same time nemopaice... now what? lol

That's ok, at least we got it going again... yours is the last one posted now

 

[fokker]

hayleyfraser - I like that the photo invokes an emotion in you, and after reading that explanation I instantly liked the photo more. But having said that, I didn't like it at a first glance, the technical flaws are just a bit much to enjoy the image overall for me personally. 5/10

HDR Photo of the Southern Star Observation Wheel being rebuilt in Melbourne. They originally had to take the wheel down after only a few weeks in use because they found cracks in the structural metal! I know the HDR effect is quite pronounced in this which is something a lot of people don't like, but I thought it suits the subject.

 

[iNick]

Cool image! Im not a huge fan of HDR but i agree it fits with this shot. The sky looks ominous and cool. Nice job. 7/10