sibling rivalry

[50two]

would you kindly point out which is to your opinion, the better edit feel free to critisise both

1

2

thanks

 

[reg]

Well, they're both really blurry photos, but I think we can all agree #2 is better.

 

[LaFoto]

The second edit does not emphasise the original flaws as much as the first does, and while I find the tones in 2 very much on the BLAND side (pale, grey), that one seems more pleasing to the eye overall, even though I must add that a photo AS blurred (camera shake, I gather) is no longer pleasing to the eye per se. I always want to adjust my glasses (pun fully intended with what she's doing herself) to get a better vision!

 

[freelunch]

Hi. I'm new here, too, but I notice that people tend to ask for critiques without stating what their objective was when they took the shot. Your top shot emphasises colour, your second shot suggests mood. I think one is not better than the other, they're different shots.

 

[reg]

they're different shots.

Au contraire, it's the exact same photo with two different photoshop treatments.

 

[Computer_Generated]

yeah I gotta agree, both really don't do it for me. I'm more of a fan for high key images so I'm gonna go with #1 if we're only talking about the photoshop aspect.