That was the point of #3, more urban and grunge. Not every shot of a pretty girl should be a beauty shot. Thanks for all the input. She and I will be headed out for another shoot soon.
I'm not feeling the processing on the first one; the line between tinted and not is too visible. If you're going to go with something like that, I think it would look better with a more organic transition. Also, with the crop and the framing, it sort of look like her neck is really long. I'm sure she's got a long graceful neck, but this shot overdoes it a bit.
Amazing how different techniques can make one person look like three totally different people. Not fan of the third one, I get a homeless feeling but the hoodie throws it off.