Aloicious
No longer a newbie, moving up!
- Joined
- Mar 12, 2010
- Messages
- 1,661
- Reaction score
- 452
- Location
- UT
- Can others edit my Photos
- Photos NOT OK to edit
I've never been sure what the attraction is for the Lee system. Seems like paying about $300 extra up front for no particular reason to me. Being able to lift them out quickly might be nice, but if you simply use live view, in most scenes even at 10 stops of ND, you can compose and even autofocus just fine with it still on.
its just personal preference really, if all you've got is sub 77mm lenses, then yeah step up rings work, but there are many lenses larger than 77, for example, my 21mm lens which I most frequently use with the lee takes 82mm front filters, and when you get into sizes like that, quality circular filters start costing very close to the $300+ range alone, with the lee setup, you have everything to use filters on a variety of lenses, then new 4x4 filters are usually around the $100-$200ish range each.
so for example if you wanted a 10 stop ND, and a .9 ND, and a .6 GND that will fit an 82mm lens, and a 77mm lens:
Lee:
foundation kit - $88
82 and 77 adapter - $28 + $60
10 stop - $140
.9 ND (glass) - $180
.6 GND (glass) - $180
Total - $676
high end circular:
10 stop B+W - $269
.9 ND B+W - $287
.6 GND B+W - $169
82mm to 77mm Step down ring - $10
Total - $735
The price starts becoming negligible or even in favor of the Lee at that point (of course there are cheaper options on either side too). also remember that the lee offers some benefits that circular filters lack, such as stacking filters on wide angles, the lee won't have nearly the same (if any) vignetting effect that stacking circular filters would. and with a GND filter, the circular ones will allow you to rotate them, but not necessarily adjust where the graduated break is in the frame, where a square GND filter is longer on one side allowing you to slide it up/down in the frame as well as rotation.
in the end both ways of doing things will get great results, and it just comes down to what you need and personal preference.
Last edited: